{"about":{"non_affiliation":"Code with Papers and Syntology are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Papers with Code, Meta, or the pwc-archive mirror.","site":"https://codewithpapers.app","licence":"CC BY-SA 4.0","licence_url":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/legalcode","attribution":"https://codewithpapers.app/attribution","modified":"archive material modified by Syntology; see the attribution page","syntology":{"site":"https://syntology.ai","developers":"https://syntology.ai/developers","mcp":{"server":"https://syntology.ai/mcp","transport":"streamable-http","server_card":"https://syntology.ai/.well-known/mcp/server-card.json","auth":{"type":"trial token, no account","trial_token":"https://syntology.ai/api/oauth/trial/token","method":"POST","docs":"https://syntology.ai/developers"}},"have":"https://syntology.ai/api/graph/have?x=<method, arXiv id or title> (free, answers coverage only)","paper_base":"https://syntology.ai/paper/","atlas_base":"https://app.syntology.ai/?focus="},"machine_readable":[{"url":"https://codewithpapers.app/llms.txt","what":"the machine catalog: every machine-readable file, counted"},{"url":"https://codewithpapers.app/index/manifest.json","what":"paper-to-code index by arXiv id, with Syntology's counts"},{"url":"https://codewithpapers.app/search/manifest.json","what":"site search index (titles, authors) and its files"},{"url":"https://codewithpapers.app/download","what":"bulk files: Syntology's layer, described there"},{"url":"https://codewithpapers.app/build_manifest.json","what":"the build record: inputs, counts, exclusions, probes"}]},"url":"/paper/critiquellm-scaling-llm-as-critic-for","title":"CritiqueLLM: Towards an Informative Critique Generation Model for Evaluation of Large Language Model Generation","arxiv_id":"2311.18702","date":"2023-11-30","proceeding":null,"authors":["Pei Ke","Bosi Wen","Zhuoer Feng","Xiao Liu","Xuanyu Lei","Jiale Cheng","Shengyuan Wang","Aohan Zeng","Yuxiao Dong","Hongning Wang","Jie Tang","Minlie Huang"],"abstract":"Since the natural language processing (NLP) community started to make large language models (LLMs) act as a critic to evaluate the quality of generated texts, most of the existing works train a critique generation model on the evaluation data labeled by GPT-4's direct prompting. We observe that these models lack the ability to generate informative critiques in both pointwise grading and pairwise comparison especially without references. As a result, their generated critiques cannot provide fine-grained distinguishability on generated texts, causing unsatisfactory evaluation performance. In this paper, we propose a simple yet effective method called Eval-Instruct, which can first acquire pointwise grading critiques with pseudo references and then revise these critiques via multi-path prompting to obtain informative evaluation data in different tasks and settings, including pointwise grading and pairwise comparison with / without references. After fine-tuning on these data, the resulting model CritiqueLLM is empirically shown to outperform ChatGPT and all the open-source baselines and even achieve comparable evaluation performance to GPT-4 in system-level correlations of pointwise grading. We also demonstrate that our generated critiques can act as scalable feedback to further improve the generation quality of strong LLMs like ChatGPT.","url_abs":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2311.18702v2","url_pdf":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.18702v2.pdf","source":{"archive":"pwc-archive (Hugging Face), CC BY-SA 4.0","snapshot":"2025-07-28","licence_url":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/legalcode","row_kind":"abstracts"},"code_links":[{"paper_slug":"critiquellm-scaling-llm-as-critic-for","repo_url":"https://github.com/thu-coai/critiquellm","is_official":1,"mentioned_in_paper":1,"mentioned_in_github":1,"framework":"none","reach":null},{"paper_slug":"critiquellm-scaling-llm-as-critic-for","repo_url":"https://github.com/thudm/alignbench","is_official":0,"mentioned_in_paper":0,"mentioned_in_github":1,"framework":"none","reach":null}],"tasks":[{"task_slug":"language-modeling","task_name":"Language Modeling"},{"task_slug":"language-modelling","task_name":"Language Modelling"},{"task_slug":"large-language-model","task_name":"Large Language Model"},{"task_slug":"model","task_name":"model"}],"methods":[{"method_slug":"absolute-position-encodings","method_name":"Absolute Position Encodings"},{"method_slug":"adam","method_name":"Adam"},{"method_slug":"attention","method_name":"Attention"},{"method_slug":"bpe","method_name":"BPE"},{"method_slug":"dense-connections","method_name":"Dense Connections"},{"method_slug":"dropout","method_name":"Dropout"},{"method_slug":"gpt-4","method_name":"GPT-4"},{"method_slug":"label-smoothing","method_name":"Label Smoothing"},{"method_slug":"layer-normalization","method_name":"Layer Normalization"},{"method_slug":"linear-layer","method_name":"Linear Layer"},{"method_slug":"multi-head-attention","method_name":"Multi-Head Attention"},{"method_slug":"position-wise-feed-forward-layer","method_name":"Position-Wise Feed-Forward Layer"},{"method_slug":"residual-connection","method_name":"Residual Connection"},{"method_slug":"softmax","method_name":"Softmax"},{"method_slug":"transformer","method_name":"Transformer"}],"datasets_introduced":[],"methods_introduced":[],"results":[],"syntology":{"syntology_url":"https://syntology.ai/paper/2311.18702","atlas_url":"https://app.syntology.ai/?focus=2311.18702","mcp":{"get_harvested_code_for_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2311.18702"},"calls":[{"tool":"get_harvested_code_for_paper","arguments":{"arxiv_id":"2311.18702"},"returns":"the samples harvested from this paper, each with its run record; it does not verify the paper"},{"tool":"get_code","arguments_in":"samples[].code_sha256","returns":"one stored sample by its code_sha256; not shown on this site"}]},"developers":"https://syntology.ai/developers","held":true,"reason":"in_graph_layer","checked_against":null,"agent_calls":[{"tool":"get_harvested_code_for_paper","arguments":{"arxiv_id":"2311.18702"},"call":"get_harvested_code_for_paper(arxiv_id=\"2311.18702\")"},{"tool":"get_code","arguments_in":{"code_sha256":"syntology.samples[].code_sha256"},"call":"get_code(code_sha256=\"…\")"},{"tool":"get_citation_path","arguments":{"paper_1":"2311.18702"},"arguments_in":{"paper_2":"another paper's arXiv id or title"},"call":"get_citation_path(paper_1=\"2311.18702\", paper_2=\"…\")"},{"tool":"get_concepts_for_paper","arguments":{"arxiv_id":"2311.18702"},"call":"get_concepts_for_paper(arxiv_id=\"2311.18702\")"}],"by_repo":[{"repo":"thu-coai/critiquellm","kind":"official","samples":5,"ran":4,"instrument":0,"unverified":1},{"repo":"thudm/alignbench","kind":"listed","samples":0,"ran":0,"instrument":0,"unverified":0,"harvested_for_other_papers":1,"harvested_for":["2311.18743"],"harvested_for_calls":[{"arxiv_id":"2311.18743","tool":"get_harvested_code_for_paper","arguments":{"arxiv_id":"2311.18743"},"call":"get_harvested_code_for_paper(arxiv_id=\"2311.18743\")"}]}],"by_repo_harvested_for_is":"harvested_for: the arXiv ids (as Syntology's graph holds them) of every paper whose samples Syntology's graph links to this repository, in arXiv-id order, complete; the page names the first 3 and says how many more. A link only: it does not say the papers are the same work, that one copied the other, or that the code implements this paper's method; harvested_for_calls gives the get_harvested_code_for_paper call for each arXiv-shaped id among them","by_repo_is":"one row per repository in the archive's code links, Syntology's graph links or the samples; samples 0 means no sample is linked to this paper, a statement about Syntology's coverage, not about the repository: with harvested_for_other_papers present, Syntology harvested the repository for that many other papers, and without it, Syntology harvested nothing from it; placed_by_identical_code counts samples whose link records no repository, placed here because identical code was harvested from this repository for another paper; ran counts executions on a synthesized input and instrument counts failures of Syntology's instrument, not of the code","read_at":"2026-10-05T00:36:11+00:00","read_at_is":"when the build read Syntology's graph, not when any sample ran","ran_record":{"url":"https://syntology.ai/api/ran/2311.18702.json","schema":"syntology.ran_record/1","counts_crosswalk":{"n_samples":"syntology.counts.lifted","n_ran":"syntology.counts.executed","n_ran_checked":"syntology.counts.checked","n_instrument":"syntology.counts.instrument_failures","n_unverified":"syntology.counts.no_recorded_run"},"note":"live record, measured at request time; may be newer than this page's graph read","badge":"https://syntology.ai/api/ran/2311.18702.svg"},"claim":"Per-sample execution status on synthesized fixtures; not a correctness claim about the paper. Samples come from repositories linked to the paper, official or community; repo_kind says which.","repos":[{"provenance":"external:paperswithcode_snapshot_2025-07-28","url":"https://github.com/thudm/alignbench","reach":null},{"provenance":"external:paperswithcode_snapshot_2025-07-28","url":"https://github.com/thu-coai/critiquellm","reach":null}],"summary":{"ran_violates":3,"ran_honours":1,"unverified":1},"n_samples":5,"n_ran":4,"n_constructed":0,"n_ran_checked":4,"n_instrument":0,"n_unverified":1,"n_instrument_is":"failures of Syntology's instrument, not of the code","every_run_is_an_instrument_failure":false,"key_notes":{"n_ran_checked":"legacy name, kept unchanged so existing readers do not break: it counts the samples that ran with no instrument failure (honoured, violated, and ran with no contract checked); it does not mean a contract was checked, and the pages print it as 'K with no instrument failure', not 'K checked'","n_constructed":"a sub-count of the samples that ran, never subtracted from them and never a failure: an executed sample whose run returned an instance of its own class (fixture_out_type equals the entry name): the run built an object and did not compute a result (Syntology's RAN record, counts.constructed)"},"by_repo_kind":{"official":{"samples":5,"ran":4,"n_ran_checked":4,"n_instrument":0,"repositories":1}},"repo_kind_vocabulary":{"official":"The archive marks this repository official for the paper","named_in_paper":"The archive records that the paper mentions this repository; it is not marked official","listed":"In the archive's code links for this paper, not marked official and not recorded as mentioned in the paper","found_in_text":"Syntology found this repository in the paper's own text; whether it is the authors' implementation is not asserted","community":"Not in the archive's code links for this paper; a community repository Syntology harvested"},"n_pointer_only_for_licence":5,"inline_ok_is":"inline_ok is true only when both licence gates allow Syntology to serve this code's text: this paper's link (inline_ok_link, from the licence of this paper's copy) and the stored copy of the same code that Syntology serves, which may have been first harvested from another repository. withheld_clause is Syntology's own wording of which gate keeps the text a pointer and why, and is null when inline_ok is true. This site shows no code text either way; n_pointer_only_for_licence counts samples with inline_ok false (both gates), n_pointer_only_link_allows those of them whose inline_ok_link is true","n_pointer_only_link_allows":0,"fixture_fields_is":{"signature_and_fixture_out_type":"the arguments Syntology's fixture called the sample with, each as name:type/rank/element kind (? where none was recorded), and the type of what the fixture's run returned, exactly as the harness recorded them; the arguments and the returned type were recorded by two separate runs of the same fixture. No output value is shown, and a returned type says nothing about whether the output was right","level_recorded_at":"when Syntology's graph wrote the sample's verification level, not when the code executed; absent where the level was written before the date was kept, and never filled in with the build date","present_on":"samples that ran only; a key is absent, never empty, where the graph records nothing"},"n_ran_with_level_date":4,"n_ran_without_level_date":0,"n_ran_signature_not_shown":0,"levels_written_between":{"first":"2026-09-22","last":"2026-09-22","is":"the first and last UTC dates on which Syntology's graph wrote a verification level for a sample on this page that ran, not when the code executed"},"code_page_min_papers":5,"code_page_is":"a page for the entry name across every paper's harvested code; the name is a string, not an identity","samples":[{"code_sha256":"0164dbe04ac52b71","code_sha256_prefix":"0164dbe04ac52b71","entry":"extract_label","repo":"thu-coai/critiquellm","repo_kind":"official","path":"evaluation/eval_pairwise.py","file_url":"https://github.com/thu-coai/critiquellm/blob/HEAD/evaluation/eval_pairwise.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"ran_violates","verification_level":1,"contract_check":"VIOLATES","metamorphic_tier":"well_formed","behaviour_fingerprint":true,"signature":"s:str/0/str","fixture_out_type":"int","level_recorded_at":"2026-09-22T14:31:46.068493+00:00","retrieve_with":{"tool":"get_code","code_sha256":"0164dbe04ac52b71"},"code_page":"/code/extract-label","census":null,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"inline_ok_link":false,"withheld_clause":"GitHub detected no licence in this paper's repository, thu-coai/critiquellm when it was checked","mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"0164dbe04ac52b71"}},{"code_sha256":"a6e47174738c4534","code_sha256_prefix":"a6e47174738c4534","entry":"extract_number","repo":"thu-coai/critiquellm","repo_kind":"official","path":"evaluation/eval_pointwise.py","file_url":"https://github.com/thu-coai/critiquellm/blob/HEAD/evaluation/eval_pointwise.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"ran_honours","verification_level":1,"contract_check":"HONOURS","metamorphic_tier":"well_formed","behaviour_fingerprint":true,"signature":"s:str/0/str","fixture_out_type":"float","level_recorded_at":"2026-09-22T14:31:46.068493+00:00","retrieve_with":{"tool":"get_code","code_sha256":"a6e47174738c4534"},"code_page":"/code/extract-number","census":null,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"inline_ok_link":false,"withheld_clause":"GitHub detected no licence in this paper's repository, thu-coai/critiquellm when it was checked","mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"a6e47174738c4534"}},{"code_sha256":"d79b3133bb83f30e","code_sha256_prefix":"d79b3133bb83f30e","entry":"kendall_corr","repo":"thu-coai/critiquellm","repo_kind":"official","path":"evaluation/eval_pointwise.py","file_url":"https://github.com/thu-coai/critiquellm/blob/HEAD/evaluation/eval_pointwise.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"ran_violates","verification_level":1,"contract_check":"VIOLATES","metamorphic_tier":"invariant","behaviour_fingerprint":true,"signature":"x:ndarray/1/float, y:ndarray/1/float","fixture_out_type":"float64","level_recorded_at":"2026-09-22T14:31:46.068493+00:00","retrieve_with":{"tool":"get_code","code_sha256":"d79b3133bb83f30e"},"code_page":null,"census":null,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"inline_ok_link":false,"withheld_clause":"GitHub detected no licence in this paper's repository, thu-coai/critiquellm when it was checked","mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"d79b3133bb83f30e"}},{"code_sha256":"6fbfe6608a41dc62","code_sha256_prefix":"6fbfe6608a41dc62","entry":"spearman_corr","repo":"thu-coai/critiquellm","repo_kind":"official","path":"evaluation/eval_pointwise.py","file_url":"https://github.com/thu-coai/critiquellm/blob/HEAD/evaluation/eval_pointwise.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"ran_violates","verification_level":1,"contract_check":"VIOLATES","metamorphic_tier":"invariant","behaviour_fingerprint":true,"signature":"x:ndarray/1/int, y:ndarray/1/int","fixture_out_type":"float64","level_recorded_at":"2026-09-22T14:31:46.068493+00:00","retrieve_with":{"tool":"get_code","code_sha256":"6fbfe6608a41dc62"},"code_page":"/code/spearman-corr","census":null,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"inline_ok_link":false,"withheld_clause":"GitHub detected no licence in this paper's repository, thu-coai/critiquellm when it was checked","mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"6fbfe6608a41dc62"}},{"code_sha256":"e4cfccf82f753bc4","code_sha256_prefix":"e4cfccf82f753bc4","entry":"read_data","repo":"thu-coai/critiquellm","repo_kind":"official","path":"inference/inference.py","file_url":"https://github.com/thu-coai/critiquellm/blob/HEAD/inference/inference.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"code_page":"/code/read-data","census":null,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"inline_ok_link":false,"withheld_clause":"GitHub detected no licence in this paper's repository, thu-coai/critiquellm when it was checked","mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"e4cfccf82f753bc4"}}]},"code_links_note":null,"arxiv_metadata":null,"syntology_extracted_results":null,"record_sha256":"fc73928fd8942696367b505d109195863a6b6bb1d64ebdd5d801b56f670e5ff4","record_changed_at":"2026-09-28","record_changed_at_basis":"first_hashed"}